I'm going to use this as a way to organize my thoughts, but hopefully I can make it readable, informative, and free of expletives.
My cousin Zach was very kind to lend me his Blu-Ray player while he was away for the month of May. Blu-ray is still a new technology, and I was excited to get a chance to play around with it to learn more about it. Here is my report. (is blu-ray review a class I could get credit for?)
Just as a note: I have 50" 720p Panasonic Plasma - In English: Middle grade HDTV
Should you buy a Blu-Ray player? If you have an older non-High Def TV - NO.
If you have an HDTV that is smaller than 42" - NO, an upcoverting DVD player will work GREAT for you.
If you have an HDTV bigger than 42" then read on.
What I HATE about Blu-Ray#1 The confusion surrounding it. Yes it will play your old DVDs, even your CDs. (There are many other confusions, but this is generally the first question)
#2 The price. New technology costs money, there is no way around it. I actually spent $300 on my first DVD player. And there are DVD players out there that still cost significantly more than that today. Hopefully in the next year we'll see quality players at an affordable price (below $200 for me)
#2.5 Disc prices. Half.com or a Netflix subscription fixes that.
#3 No resume play. On some (not all) Blu-Rays, once you've turned off the player, or even pressed stop, you have to start the movie all over again. It does not automatically resume where you left off. My current DVD player remembers where you were, even if you've watched another movie. Once you put your disc back in, it remembers where you were and starts playing from there. Debbie put it best when she said that, "Even VHS starts where you left off!" Hopefully this can be fixed by a different player, but from what I understand, the Playstation 3 (aka: Best Blu-Ray player) has this limitation
**EDIT - I don't know how I forgot my biggest gripe with Blu-Ray**
#4 Load Times. The movies take 1-3 minutes to load and get started, then with any previews, it takes even longer to get to your movie. I'm willing to suffer with load times, but mixed with no resume play... I get get furious.
What I LOVE about Blu-Ray and why it NEEDS to survive and thrive#1 High Definition!! It is one of those things that you read or hear about, but can't understand till you've seen it. Even seeing it played on 50 screens at Best Buy doesn't do it justice. You need to sit in a dark room with no distractions, a perfect setting to just bask and be amazed!
#2 Better audio. I don't have a completely up-to-date audio system, so I didn't hear all that Blu-Ray has to offer with audio, but I was very impressed with what I did hear.
*Side note* - If you don't have a surround sound system you need to get one. Without it you are missing out on a great experience. I liken it to covering up the bottom 1/4th of your screen. Sure you can see what is going on, but you're missing out on all of the fun.
#3 Classic Movies, Past, Present, and Future. Anybody that came to my house this month heard me explain this. I rented the movie Sleeping Beauty. This movie came to theaters over 50 years ago. In those 50 years it was very rarely seen by people in theaters, most people saw it on TV, VHS, or DVD. Without ranting a tremendous amount I'll wrap it up in one sentence.
Only now with Blu-ray can the hard work, detail, talent, and dedication of artists been seen by everyone. Sleeping Beauty and Wall-E looked phenomenal! Without Blu-Ray we'd never see or appreciate what talent is really out there.
#4 Who needs the theater? I'll admit I love midnight movies with a theater filled with geeks, but beyond that, the experience I have in my home is far superior. I don't have to go anywhere, I can eat whatever I want, I can pause when I want, and the seats are way more comfortable. It was shocking when I realized that I have no desire to see any movies from this summer. I'm perfectly happy just waiting for the time when I can watch at home
#5 Everyone can benefit from Blu-Ray and High Definition. Whether you love movies, sports, music, or nature, I guarantee you'll be incredibly happy with Blu-Ray.
One last point that isn't really a pro or conDisc vs. Download
You can buy and rent HD movies online through all different types of sources. Sure it is more convenient, but here are the facts. Downloaded or streaming movies cannot produce the same quality and experience as a Blu-Ray disc. Sure maybe someday we'll be able to download a full quality movie, but internet speeds for even the fastest of us aren't spectacular. It will be a long time before any person or company wants to pay to download 50GB files all the time. People could argue this, but I'm on the side of physical media.
Let's get this over withSo in conclusion I love Blu-Ray. It still has its fault (see above) which is why I'm willing to wait another 6 months to a year before I get my own player. As much as I don't want to, I'm going to suffer through upcoverted DVDs, patiently waiting for the day...